You are on page 4. Click the red cross to clear.
It was suggested earlier in the season that when both sides are grappling each other in the area that the ref blows for a free kick to the defending side. Not an ideal solution but might work
14th May 2026 10:33:29
[81.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
Not really a defence of VAR or referees but now both defence and attack commit fouls at every corner. Whilst you haven't stopped that then you can only intervene where there is a clear effect on whether a goal is scored or not. If anyone can think of how to solve the underlying problem other than randomly awarding free kicks and penalties, I'm sure the authorities would like to hear it.
14th May 2026 10:22:53
[86.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
For me VAR has ruined the spontaneity, I remember the 1979 cup final when Arsenal threw away a 2-0 lead only to score a last gasp winner to win 3-2 and thinking that was he ultimate in glory but nowadays you’d have to wait a few minutes so the moment would be gone. Even in cricket when England won the World Cup there was a check to see if Jos Buttler had done the last ball run out correctly
14th May 2026 10:19:48
[81.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
But VAR (correctly) ruled that goal out whilst not intervening on a number of other similar goals (many for Arsenal) throughout the season.
14th May 2026 10:13:54
[195.lo.gg.ed]
VAR has not solved the inconsistency issue. (I actually like inconsistency in football - referees should be encouraged to officiate games depending on the tone of the game and the behaviour of the players)
CW, I dislike VAR with a passion. I so preferred the days where fans could argue that the decision was right or wrong, that applied right down to grassroots. You could say the ref was crooked and for evermore debate the decision. The great thing for me is that the EFL currently have that model and the debates continue. Fans celebrate, or berate officials in real-time moments of agony or jubilation and the game goes on. You win some and lose some, but I'm so glad a finger or toenail decides our matches and don't have to wait minutes to celebrate again, or hear that song, "you thought you had scored, you were wrong, you were wrong"
14th May 2026 10:12:09
[146.lo.gg.ed]
Bottom line is there has to be an implied notion that the officials are honest, they are human, make mistakes and sometimes are just pure brilliant at sometimes getting a decision right that on a TV screen at 10pm you see the incident and think wow, great reffing.
I’m not a fan of VAR but clearly the ref didn’t see the big incident at the end of the Westham game so without that the title would be heading to Man City
14th May 2026 09:58:31
[81.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
Just seen that in an amazing and unexpected career change Jedward now play in goal for Bristol Rovers.
14th May 2026 09:40:43
[195.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
Of course it was never a penalty in the 1988 Cup Final.
14th May 2026 09:33:42
[86.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
They always used to say back in the day that Juventus would get a dodgy penalty to win the vital game, remember Liam Brady scoring a late penalty one year to do just this
14th May 2026 09:18:22
[81.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
Trig - the commentators celebrate them as they're getting a bit nervy that Celtic and Citeh won't win their respective leagues
14th May 2026 08:14:52
[5.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
Football is broken. I’m gonna stop watching Sky Sports because these decisions keep happening and the commentators celebrate them. VAR has destroyed the integrity of the top flight. It hasn’t solved a problem that didn’t need solving and has introduced a new problem of people miles away from the stadium pouring over every incident to see if they can change the outcome.
13th May 2026 22:00:00
[195.lo.gg.ed]
Independent football regulator already conflicted so will be as much use as expected.
Trigg - exactly, but they really don’t want anyone else to win the title other than the usual pair 🙄
13th May 2026 21:51:08
[104.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
Celtic are going to get a dodgy penalty to help them win the title 🙄🤦🏻♂️
13th May 2026 21:45:50
[104.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
Padd - only if Celtic concede again…
13th May 2026 21:43:09
[104.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
Trig- they're saying that as things stand Hearts are champions.
13th May 2026 21:41:36
[87.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
So as things stand (hearts have scored a 3rd goal but I don’t think it changes anything) Celtic will need to win by 3 clear goals on Saturday to snatch the title.
13th May 2026 21:39:30
[195.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
2-2 but still minutes to go….
13th May 2026 21:34:59
[104.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU
Reading the BBC report on Southampton and Middlesborough it is going to end up costing us money because the EFL will get taken to court and settle before trial using the money of the 72 clubs whatever their decision. I'd leave Southampton in as the settlement with them would be much higher.
13th May 2026 21:34:47
[86.lo.gg.ed]
Ex www.wup.me.uk - The home of WU